Four patterns. One of them is the absence of a pattern.
A correlation here is only a straight-line relationship in this mirror. r runs from −1 to 1. Near 0 means the two numbers ignore each other. It is not proof of a cause.
Older filing years show more openings
A strong pattern: these two numbers rise together (r = 0.79).
From 2018 to 2025 the opened share falls from about one in five to about one in twenty. Part of that is the clock. A case filed recently has had less time to be unsealed. It is not the whole story: even 2018, with years to open, stays near 21%.
Criminal numbers open. Most other numbers do not.
71.4% of sealed criminal numbers from 2019–2025 were later opened, against 8.6% of the other sealed numbers.
That is 30,180 criminal openings out of 42,297, and 44,384 other openings out of 514,469. A magistrate complaint often becomes a public criminal case under a new number. This sheet follows the old number, so the magistrate line can stay “sealed” after the matter is public.
Bigger sealed dockets open a smaller share
A weak pattern: these two numbers move in opposite directions (r = -0.37).
Measured across 88 courts with at least 500 sealed filings in 2019–2025, but plotted for every large docket. Massachusetts is the obvious pull: a huge sealed list, almost none later opened. The cloud is wide. Volume is a hint, not a rule.
Magistrate share does not pick the secretive courts
Almost no straight-line relationship (r = -0.03).
This is the useful negative. A court can be mostly magistrate numbers and still open most of them. Eastern Missouri is the example. The habit lives in the district, not in the docket code.
Opened later, by the year the case was filed
2026 sits at zero because no openings are filled in yet. Do not read that dot as a new policy.
Each dot is a court
Across: how many sealed filings. Up: share later opened.
What the 2026 sealed numbers actually are
The workbook’s case list for 2026 has 64,491 case numbers, one for each sealed filing that year. The letters inside the number are the court’s own code. Magistrate numbers dominate. Criminal numbers are a thin slice. Search warrants are sealed because that is how a warrant works before it is executed.
Magistrate numbers are 72.7% of the 2026 list. Criminal numbers are 6.2%.
Criminal, 2019–2025
71.4%
later marked opened
Everything else sealed, 2019–2025
8.6%
later marked opened
Spring 2020, month by month
Brass is filed in public. Red is filed under seal. The public line falls off a cliff in April 2020: 16,664 public filings in April 2019, 4,691 in April 2020. Sealed filings that same month went from 5,860 to 6,512. For one month, sealed filings were the majority of the count. That had not been true in any full year.
The late-summer rise in the red line is partly a reporting dump, not a second wave of sealing. August 2020 counts 9,700 sealed filings, and 3,103 of them are the Northern District of Illinois backlog already flagged below. September is 10,748, of which 2,623 are that same court. Take those two rows out and the national sealed line does not spike.
Where the public cases disappeared
March through May. The volume is on the southwest border. Southern Texas, Western Texas, Arizona, and Southern California file enormous public criminal dockets in a normal spring. Those dockets shrank. Their sealed counts barely moved. Central California and Southern New York were already mostly sealed; their public slice got smaller still, and the sealed count held.
S.D. Texas. Sealed 467 to 359. Public 12,260 to 5,398.
W.D. Texas. Sealed 771 to 752. Public 9,274 to 3,178.
Arizona. Sealed 392 to 528. Public 8,887 to 2,463.
S.D. California. Sealed 300 to 330. Public 4,431 to 1,830.
C.D. California. Sealed 1,682 to 1,723. Public 635 to 299.
S.D. New York. Sealed 647 to 739. Public 350 to 143.
Sealed warrants, two different lists
A warrant is sealed so the search is not announced before it happens. This mirror sees that in two places, and they are not the same count. The 2026 case-number list above is every sealed number that year: magistrate numbers dominate, and 5,241 use the search-warrant code. The chart below is only the named-update sheet, numbers that later received a public caption. A warrant that stays sealed never appears on it. A court can lead this chart and still open a large share of its sealed filings. The chart is who got a caption, not who files the most warrants.
Captions that name a tool, not a person
Search warrants, phones, pen registers, tracking warrants, and other warrants. The jump in 2025 and 2026 follows the jump in how many updates the sheet matched at all, not a measured national surge. In 2020, search-warrant captions were 303 of 863 named updates. In 2022 they were 92 of 560.
Courts with the most of those captions
S.D. Ohio2,002
Arizona1,317
C.D. California472
W.D. Oklahoma416
E.D. Missouri389
N.D. Florida345
S.D. Texas336
E.D. Virginia222
The same numbers, grouped into circuits
Red is filed under seal. Green was later marked opened. The Ninth Circuit holds the largest sealed count because it holds the largest courts, including Central California. The Eighth opens the biggest share. The Eleventh looks small partly because the Northern District of Georgia is not in this mirror.
A few months are not months. They are dumps.
A row is flagged when the sealed count is at least eight times that court’s own median month, and at least 80 cases. That rule catches 22 court-months and 16,858 sealed filings — 2.4% of the national total, so it does not move the countrywide rate. It does rewrite one court.
Northern District of Illinois
A typical month there is 10 sealed cases. 14 months blow past that, and they hold 15,709 of the court’s 16,615 sealed filings. Only 119 of those were later marked opened. The other months opened 525 of 906. The court’s headline open rate is mostly those dumped rows, not a decade of ordinary practice. Open the file before quoting the rate.
Northern District of Illinois, 2020-08
3,103 sealed against a median month of 10. 16 later opened. 121 public. IL-N_20-Aug.csv